Coney Island Hot Dogs in New Castle

I like the hot dogs and fries with chili

Coney Island has been a staple for my family since I can remember. Love their chili dogs and fries. I highly recommend always going with onions in your chili dogs and chili burgers! Best chili anywhere. Oh, and their staff? A 10 out of 10!

I have been visiting Coney Island since I was little. The whole family still visit the place almost every time we return to Youngstown area. Best hot dogs ever. Yes, it's cash only, what's the big deal. Our father found the original way back in the 50's or 60's. Try the everything dogs; mustard, strong onions, and their Chilli. Grab a pint or quart to go. Get sauce on fries too.

Great as always. The drive thru time kinda sucked.

I've enjoyed these coney dogs for over 50 years. By far the best there are. Price has stayed very low and quality has stayed very high.

This place rocks. The burgers are excellent in taste and price. The hot dogs are just as good as the burgers. Get the fries with real shredded cheese and not some fake cheese sauce. I have driven by this place so many times and dismissed it as another hole in the wall, but wow, was I surprised. Stop in and you will not be disappointed.

Spicy sauce. Just spicy enough!

Just as good as I remember

Great food. Fast service

I didn"t like there hot dog sauce! Won"t eat there again..

Drive-Thru service is as slow as malassas in the winter.

great prices double cheese burger good. chille a bit too hot for me. The last time I was here. the manager. Logan ,was adamant that we finish our food and get out before 10 even though we had asked before ordering if it was too late. rude.

As always Great Food!!! The staff was awesome too

We Love Coney Island! Best Hot Dogs & Chili Cheese Fries around! Nice Clean Dining area and the Restrooms are Clean too. Friendly Employees Always have a Smile & Friendly! 5⭐ from Me!

Coney Island always the best ! I grew up on on Coney dogs. As kids we used to ride our bikes there.

Can eat food, makes me extremely sick. Sorry.

THE BEST chili dogs ever. I grew up on Coney dogs, and many have tried to duplicate the recipe, but no one has come close to how good theirs is. A staple in my experience when coming home when I lived in Florida.

Love it here. Great hotdogs

I’m not from New Castle but my wife is - Coney Island is just another example of how good the food is there! Get a couple of conies with everything on them, the chili, mustard and onions go so well together. We fed 4 people for like 12 bucks!

This was a really good visit! Food taste great and I did not have to pull up to wait for cheeseburger lime we usually do, drive thru was fast.

Been going there since my wife's family started dragging me there almost 40 years ago and always go back when in town.. great Chili on the dogs!

They have the best dogs around. I moved to Sharon and drive to New Castle at least 3 times a month just for a Coney Island chili dog

Very good dogs and sauce.

1st time there and they had good dogs!Will definitely go back.Good prices and friendly staff!

Great chili dogs!

Great food great atmosphere but the dirty sanchez was a bit scary but well enjoyed

Not the same as when I was a kid.. o have eat there for 40 years, other people can tell as well

Our family has tried to eat here twice and both times we stood there waiting to order! I don't know if it was because there were a lot of younger teens working and really no manager or maybe its because my husband is a bigger guy and they thought it would be funnier to stand there staring?! So we have literally had to walk out! And we love the food here. But its been 2 years and still have not been back. Smh

Great hotdogs good choices to pick from friendly workers

Food is always good but the drive thru is ridiculously slow. There should be no reason a customer would have to wait 20 minutes!! You need a better system to make the line move a little quicker

Always good hot dogs. Please continue the tradition !

The best food in town for a quick bite

Absolutely love their sauce. Worth the trip only 2nd to 1

Food is as always great, but 5 employees were not wearing masks properly, including a manager.

Good food. Friendly service. The chili is a bit spicy but I loved it. Only bad thing is when you ask for cheese, its shredded not the pourable or dipping kind.

Coney island is a great place for a quick, cheap meal. They also offer their chili for sale, as well as the seasoning they order for their recipe. I was a bit disappointed that the cheese was just shredded and not liquid. When used with the chili, that's fine. However, my girls like cheese dogs and were disappointed in the shredded cheese.

I stop everytime I'm back in the area. Last 2 trips the chili was cold. Disappointing to say the least. I loved this place since I was a kid.

Family tradition to stop every time we're in New Castle. Of course we just have to take home a few quarts of sauce!!!!!!

Okay because of my being born and raised on Coney Island Chili. Fries and chili were cold. But, well worth the price. Fair and reasonable. Always go back when I am in town.

Some of the best chili cheese fries I've ever had.

Always the best dogs around

Always good food here. Seems like a friendly staff. Dining area was a bit dirty but it was right after lunch hours so it is what it is. To be fair, employees were attempting to clean it up, just moving kind of slow. All in all, a slightly above average experience.

This has always been a family favorite. Heck we drive almost 2 hours just to get there. Many have tried to make it but never gets duplicated.

Good chili! Better than hot dog shoppes chili. Nice quiet spot to eat

I love coney island chili sauce. Everytime Im in New Castle I stop and eat there. Drive thru line is always long.